Page 148 - 15Diarrhoeaandvomiting
P. 148

Other therapies




                           in the study were divided into two groups according to their hospital file number on admission,
                           and thus allocation concealment was inadequate. The trial assessed the effect of administering
                           0.3 g/kg per day of glutamine in the treatment of acute diarrhoea in children. Mothers administered
                           the supplement (glutamine or placebo) in three daily doses for 7 days. The authors reported that
                           patients (and carers) and assessors were blinded to the treatment received and the sample size
                           was calculated based on a preliminary study that looked at duration of diarrhoea in 15 subjects.
                           The outcome considered was duration of the diarrhoeal episode. [EL = 1−]

                           Loss to follow-up was nearly 20%. The comparability between the two groups at the start
                           of the trial was adequate. The mean duration of diarrhoea in the group receiving glutamine
                           (n = 63, mean 3.40 days, SD 1.96 days) was shorter than in the control group (n = 65, mean
                           4.57 days, SD 2.48 days). This finding was statistically significant (WMD −1.17 days; 95% CI
                           −1.94 to −0.40 days). Data relating to duration of diarrhoea after treatment were stratified
                           by  stool  frequency  on  admission.  Children  in  the  glutamine  group  with  a  stool  frequency
                           below eight per day (n = 46) had a mean duration of diarrhoea of 3.30 days (SD 1.96 days)
                           compared with 4.68 days (SD 2.60 days) in those receiving the placebo (n = 41). This finding
                           was statistically significant (WMD −1.38 days; 95% CI −2.36 to −0.40 days). When the data
                           collected  from  the  children  with  high  stool  frequency,  eight  or  more  stools  per  day,  were
                           analysed, no statistically significant difference in mean duration of diarrhoea was observed
                           between the groups. No statistically significant differences in the proportion with persistent
                           diarrhoea or vomiting were found.

                           Evidence summary
                           There was a lack of high-quality evidence for the effectiveness of glutamine supplementation
                           in the treatment of acute diarrhoea in children. A quasi-randomised controlled trial conducted
                           in Turkey [EL = 1−] showed no difference in the onset of persistent diarrhoea or vomiting. On
                           the other hand, the study suggested that glutamine supplementation shortens the duration of
                           diarrhoea by 1 day.

               8.3.4       Folic acid

                           Evidence overview

                           A single study located in Bangladesh was identified as relevant and included in the review. 179
                           This RCT recruited 106 male children aged between 6 and 23 months who presented with watery
                           diarrhoea (of less than 72 hours’ duration) and some degree of dehydration. They were enrolled
                           after admission into the study ward. The participants were randomised into two treatment arms:
                           those receiving 5 mg folate (n = 54) and those receiving placebo (n = 52) every 8 hours for 5 days.
                           The method of randomisation and allocation concealment were not reported by the authors.
                           Subjects and investigators were blinded to the treatment administered. A power calculation was
                           performed. The outcomes measured were course of illness, stool output, ORS solution intake and
                           IV fluids received. [EL = 1+]
                           Baseline comparability between the two groups was adequate but loss to follow-up was not
                           reported. No statistically significant differences were observed between the two groups for the
                           mean duration of diarrhoea, the proportion having diarrhoea beyond 5 days, the mean total stool
                           output, the mean total intake of ORS solution or the proportion of all children receiving IVT.
                           Data were also analysed for rotavirus-positive children (n = 63) and the results did not show any
                           statistically significant differences in the intake, output or duration of diarrhoea between the folic
                           acid group (n = 34) and the placebo group (n = 29).

                           Evidence summary
                           Evidence  from  an  RCT  [EL  =  1+]  located  in  Bangladesh  suggested  that  5  days  of  folate
                           supplementation for the treatment of children with acute diarrhoea did not reduce the duration
                           of diarrhoea, the stool output, the ORS solution intake or the number of children requiring IVT.








                                                                                                         123
   143   144   145   146   147   148   149   150   151   152   153